The Cheeseburger Controversy Dividing the Internet

“Here’s a dumb thing that grill chefs do,” opens Deadspin writer Chris Thompson’s polemic against conventional cheeseburger grilling methods, published last week. “They flip the burgers on the grill, and then, while the burgers finish cooking, the chef lays slices of cheese on the top of the burgers, where presumably the heat of the grill will aid in the melting of the cheese.”

How to Make the Genius Smashed Cheeseburger Even Juicier

How to Make the Genius Smashed Cheeseburger Even Juicier by Sarah Jampel

All wrong, Thompson says. This practice relies on a miscalculation—an overestimation, really—of how much heat a slab of cheese requires to melt, ignoring the fact that patties carry vestigial heat that allows cheese to melt just fine when the patties are removed from their heating surfaces. Subjecting your cheese to such aggressive heat makes it look like a thin layer of foil atop a burger, folding onto the burger’s sides. What’s more is that he claims it leads to a terribly dirty grill, strewn with shreds of dairy.

Thompson also cautions against heaping the burger’s accoutrements, produce, and condiments. This, he claims, guarantees you’ll mutate the cheeseburger into “a slick, sliding mess” where cheese is, once again, the casualty, cruelly pushed aside.

Building the Perfect Cheeseburger

Building the Perfect Cheeseburger by Ashley Rodriguez

Instead, he recommends:

  1. Before you remove the burger patty from the grill, put all the cheese you’d like onto the top bun.
  2. Take the burger patty off the grill and lay it down onto the cheese / top bun.
  3. Stack the bottom bun with condiments and whatever else your heart desires.
  4. Slap the top half of the burger onto the bottom.

The Oh-So-Simple Chicken Dinner(s) We Showed Off on the TODAY Show

The Oh-So-Simple Chicken Dinner(s) We Showed Off on the TODAY Show by Food52

And there you go. It’s a surefire way, Thompson says, of making sure that the cheese melts and stays to the top of the bun so that it’s spread out evenly across the burger’s perimeter. That way, every bite is soaked with pleasure.

Thompson’s irreverent article—a mere blog post on the internet!—certainly struck a nerve: Just take a look at the comments section, where he’s pilloried for expressing an opinion and presenting it as fact. Our friends at the Today Show devoted a whole segment to the issue wherein they expressed bewilderment over Thompson’s methods, echoing popular opinion. When the Today Show polled its viewership on Twitter, consensus overwhelmingly skewed towards putting cheese on the burger while it’s still on the grill.

Help us with an upcoming Trending segment.

When making a cheeseburger, do you add the cheese while on the grill or after grilling?

— TODAY (@TODAYshow) August 7, 2017

Quite the contrarian stance, Mr. Thompson. I’ve got no real horse in this race, so I’d like to know: Do you find his method all that radical? When’s the best time to put cheese on a cheeseburger? Please let me know. Vote in our poll. We’d like to hear from you.

When’s the best time to put cheese on a cheeseburger? 🍔

— Food52 (@Food52) August 14, 2017

This article was written by Mayukh Sen from Food52 and was legally licensed through the NewsCred publisher network. Please direct all licensing questions to